-
AuthorPosts
-
Dear Moomchil,
Please excuse the typo on your name.
Best regards
Mark
Dear moomchil,
Sarcasm maybe, but equally serious, because I am a former officer of HM Customs & Excise and used to deal extensively with Transit Shed activities at the Port of London, hence my sharp and radical views. It was often the case that consignments would be sitting in the Transit Shed for more than three days because of the need for decisions from higher up the Customs scale concerning major issues such as value, description, origin, and so on. Nobody will tell me that 3 days is sufficient, because that is simply not true. In any case, moving the goods to a customs warehouse was also commonplace, especially if more in-depth Customs examinations were necessary and could not be carried out at the Transit Shed.
My sarcasm is also a view concerning the right of the trader to have access to duty reliefs and deferment. The EU guarantee policy also concerns preferential origin. I know this because HMRC has placed origin on its list of high-risk areas, especially as country of origin does not necessarily equal country of despatch. Furthermore, the re are two forms of debt, namely actual and potential. Actual debt means deferment or payment outright, whereas potential debt refers to issues such as duty relief and origin. Financial guarantee requirements make it increasingly difficult for traders to use duty reliefs, thus deterring them from applying for duty relief in the first place. This of course plays straight into the EU’s hands, as it basically means no-win for the trader, which is not the purpose of import duty reliefs. Heads they win, tails we lose.
Another vexing issue is that in some cases, the UK has more excise duty reliefs than in the EU, as in the facility of excise duty drawback, Tied Oils Relief (used for lubricants, white spirits and greases) and more use of excise duty reliefs in the form of movement of goods under duty suspension, or where hydrocarbons are converted into such non-excisable products, including the use of ethanol and bio-ethanol products. In the Czech Republic, for example, excise goods cannot be moved under duty suspension to the UK, and duty must be paid on production. This can only be made subject to duty drawback once it has been proven that the excise goods, such as hydrocarbon-based goods, have reached the UK. Furthermore, there is no facility for Tied Oils Relief in either the Republic of Ireland or the Czech Republic, and I have a wealth of experience in dealing with these issues. Sarcasm maybe not. Realism yes definitely, and that is why I have major problems with the EU and its revenue strategy, especially concerning Indirect taxes as a whole. Clearly, the EU does not like duty reliefs of any kind, as it fears a loss of coveted revenue.
There is a distinct problem with EU revenue policy, and it is that which needs urgent reform.
Mark
Dear Mark
Thank you for the comprehensive answer and I completely understand your sarcasm. Unfortunately, we are still in the EU and considering the practice in Bulgaria, I would say that a short period of temporary storage would be a problem not only for the EO, but also for the customs authority… they cannot organise themselves to process these consignments, especially if, for example, veterinary or phytosanitary control is required, it becomes “mission impossible”.
I am familiar with CLECAT’s position and we also support the efforts of Nicolette and her team in this direction, but it seems that the Commission really does not want to deal with the problem and does not consider how realistic their proposal is. We’ll keep an eye on what happens, let’s hope logic prevails :)
Momchil
Momchil,
I know that this is likely to happen, and I will tell you why. If you consult the Union Customs Code, you will see that several measures were introduced to “protect” Import Duty and VAT Revenue for the EU. Duty Drawback was removed, more stringent measures were introduced concerning import duty reliefs, and stiff financial guarantees were required for both duty deferment accounts and applications for Inward processing and Customs Warehousing, unless, that is, the applicants were already AEO approved, which most applicants are not. In any case, AEO status is difficult to achieve. Furthermore, the Lithuanian Free Economic Zone was only allowed to exist as long as it did not approve Customs Duty and VAT Relief facilities within the Free Zone.
This was one of the main elements of Brexit. The moment the UK left the EU, it lowered all its Customs Tariffs and generally removed the need for Financial Guarantees on Import Duty Relief applications, as well as implementing Postponed VAT Accounting. The only stupidities that HMRC insisted on were AEO status for all Freeport operators and specific areas for Customs-controlled manufacturing. These measures fly in the face of global Free Zone management, requires none of these restrictions.
In short, the EU is desperate to protect Customs Import Duties and VAT as much as possible, and has no intention of allowing more duty relief than is absolutely necessary, if at all. It certainly has no intention of relaxing the rules concerning Customs-suspended storage, and will tighten these rules as much a possible. The so-called “Customs Reform” certainly dates back just over a year, when the EU proposed a reduction in Temporary Storage time to 3 or 6 days, depending upon the operator’s authorisation. This time limit is useless, as much temporary storage revolves around Transit Sheds, where goods may be temporarily stored until they are either removed to a Customs Warehouse, brought into Free Circulation, or re-exported on an outbound vessel or aircraft. The “risk factor” as mentioned in the article on this original proposal does not have any credibility, as risk factors are already taken into account by the agents when depositing goods into Temporary Storage. The main issue is that the EU wants revenue on these goods, and will do anything to gain it, regardless of the ethics of such activities.
However, the European Freight Forwarding Organisation CLECAT pointed out that Customs Warehousing in its current form was not an alternative for temporary storage. It said: “The commission seems to underestimate that the requirement for an authorisation and the management of a customs warehouse are much more complex than for temporary storage”. From this, it would appear that the EU Commission has no knowledge of Temporary Storage and Customs Warehousing, including Freeports, whatsoever. They need educating as soon as possible. Even a period of 20 days Temporary Storage is too little. Maybe between 30 and 40 days might be more realistic.
Long live the UK’s isolation from the EU!
Mark Rowbotham
Hello colleagues,
I hope you are all doing well!
Yesterday we had a meeting with the Bulgarian customs administration about a change they are preparing in the AEO monitoring methodology, but they also mentioned something that surprised and worried me – next week there will be a meeting in Brussels at the level of the customs administrations of the MS, where the question of the temporary storage period will again be raised. It can’t be 90 days, it won’t be 3 or 6 days either… The Commission has insisted on looking for a compromise option (maybe the previous period of 45/20 days, I don’t know).
I thought this page of “reform” was closed, but there will be surprises again…
Has anyone more information on this issue?
Have a nice weekend!
Dear All,
I hope you are doing well.
I’ve attended Confiad http://www.confiad.org meeting on Friday, where the future role (considering the Reform) of customs brokers has been discussed – the current draft Code doesn’t provide much optimism for the profession. Also on Friday the US published the continuous professional development requirements for customs brokers, this way strengthening their role. Maybe this could be a good way for the EU to proceed? Please see an overview and some thoughts for a discussion attached.
Kind regards,
EnrikaI completely agree with everything Enrika says. For me, the most worrying thing is the period in which the reform is to be carried out, bearing in mind that 27 countries should be involved in it. It is quite possible that by 2038 this number will change (up, down… who knows) and this will further complicate the reform.
The current UCC has been in effect for 7 years and we are still learning how to apply it. How long will it take us to learn to implement the next…? I am generally an optimist, but even at the stage of discussing the reform project, I hear different opinions about what lies ahead. Recently in this regard we had a meeting with the Bulgarian customs authorities and I heard some different interpretations of what was being circulated among the customs community… The most disturbing thing for me was the “vision” that only AEOs should be allowed to provide the service in customs brokerage. Please forgive me if I am wrong, but I did not see such a thing in the project for a new UCC
Let’s hope that the next customs code is not interpreted in 27 different ways, because that will lead to the current state at the expense of a lot of effort by everyone
Thanks Enrika, for your very well thought through response.
Hello,
Thank you, Kevin, for starting the discussion.
Some initial thoughts (based also on the article by Michael Lux https://www.customsclearance.net/en/articles/the-reform-of-the-ucc):- Non-harmonized formalities (27 interpretations of EU customs law) are an issue. EU Customs Authority and EU Customs Data Hub should solve this – good development for all businesses. The issue – the long implementation (2038), in a rapidly changing world much becomes irrelevant fast.
- A good development for carriers and other non-importers/any-persons is that the importer will have more compliance responsibilities. Importer is redefined – the importer shall in principle be the person who is authorised to determine and has determined that the goods are brought into the customs territory of the Union from a third country. Moreover, deemed importer’s definition is introduced in e-commerce.
- E-commerce – the VAT registrations in various member states is a challenge, which will be solved abolishing the 150 Eur value duty exemption and allowing IOSS to be used independently from the value of a shipment.
- ‘Trust and check’ is being critised as a marketing title used for current self-assessment simplification, which failed to be implemented. Hopefully, now it will be implemented as ‘Trust and check’.
- Harmonisation of infringements and sanctions in the members states will be not sufficiently achieved under current proposal.
Regarding Maritime Single Window – Klaipeda port (Lithuania) is in the stage of ‘starting thinking’ about it, as far as know, probably member states will go their pace.
Good morning, I would to start a discussion around members views on EU Customs Reform and associated trade facilitation topics. Please see the following areas for consideration and response
1.What impact do you expect the measures in the EU Customs Reform will have on EU businesses
a)Large businesses
b)Small businesses
c)Logistics providers
d)Customs brokers
2.Specifically on the ‘Trust and Check’ announcements do you consider that the trade community is ready for trust and check?
What can be done to help the trade community get ready for trust and check
3.On a separate note and building on Zandra’s point last week on Returned Goods Relief (RGR) what would you like to see changed to increase use of RGR
4.If any members have been involved in the European Maritime Single Window we would be interested in any experiences you can share – such as what went well, what can be learnt prior to developing the EU Single Customs Window environment
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.






